The Islander found herself at the centre of drama when Mike picked her knowing how Chris felt about her.
However, Olivia’s feelings for Chris wasn’t completely reciprocated when the Islander admitted that she didn’t know who she liked.
In the beach hut, she confessed: “I hope it’s not something I come to regret because he’s a wonderful boy, he’s beautiful looking, he’s kind, but I’m going to give Mike a fair chance because he chose me but I’ve got nothing but respect and love for Chris really.
“The next couple of days will be the decider in a way.”
Love Island: Jessica Shears calls out Olivia over her feelings for Mike Thalassitis: Jessica Shears dismissed Olivia’s claims that she didn’t do anything with Mike when they were in bed together [ITV]
But as the day went on, Olivia seemed to warm to Mike as the pair got cosy in bed together.
While it was clear that they became close, Olivia insisted that the pair simply kissed during a chat in the beach hut.
“We had a little smooch, it wasn’t like a neck on, it was like a little kiss,” she stated.
However, it appears Olivia wasn’t telling the whole truth as Jessica quickly explained what really happened.
“She was like ‘oh we just had a bedtime kiss’ and I was like ‘babe’, literally me and Dom were sat watching it like ‘what is she doing?’ It was more than just a kiss.”
As Olivia continued to ponder over her decisions, tensions began to rise between Chris and Mike.
Love Island: Jessica Shears calls out Olivia over her feelings for Mike Thalassitis: Chris was left seething in the aftermath of the re-coupling when Mike picked Olivia [ITV]
Love Island: Jessica Shears calls out Olivia over her feelings for Mike Thalassitis: Olivia is left confused over her feelings for Mike and Chris after the re-coupling drama [ITV]
Letting off steam about Mike, Chris told the cameras in the beach hut: “Mike is a mug, he said some horrible things to Liv and I’m not going to forget that and it was almost a reminder to her that he has bitched about her behind her back which isn’t very nice.”
And after Mike called him out for talking about him behind his back, the two men sat down to talk about the drama.
“I want the best for her because I care about her. So if she chooses you I don’t want you to go and do all the bitchy stuff like you did on the first night. Because I care about her.”
Love Island: Jessica Shears calls out Olivia over her feelings for Mike Thalassitis: Olivia and Mike got close in the bedroom during the latest episode [ITV]
Refusing to let Chris have the last word, Mike declared: “Listen you can call it b****y but what you did today was b****y. You stand up there, call me ‘Muggy Mike’ and when I call you and say ‘look have you got anything to say come and say it’ you don’t. And you never said nothing to me.”
While the pair came to an agreement to move on, it appears that Chris wasn’t ready to let go just yet.
“Mike is a mug, there’s ways of doing things.
“If you want to graft and you want to do that kind of thing, there’s a way of doing it and if he does need some tips then he can talk to me, but yeah, Muggy Mike.
Love Island: Jessica Shears calls out Olivia over her feelings for Mike Thalassitis: After the re-coupling drama, Mike and Chris attempted to talk through their differences [ITV]
“You should forgive but you shouldn’t forget in this life and obviously with me it’s hard for me to bite my tongue in situations like that, especially when I care about the people involved.”
Love Island continues on ITV2 at 9pm.